Print Page   |   Contact Us   |   Sign In   |   Register
Community Search
Giving Volunteers Feedback
Share |

Giving Volunteers Feedback – Subscriber Circle Summary & Tips

Sammy Feilchenfeld, Training Coordinator

In March 2015, a number of volunteer managers and coordinators from Toronto’s non-profit and charitable organizations came together to discuss “Giving Volunteers Feedback” at Volunteer Toronto’s Subscriber Circle. Here are a few key highlights and tips from the session:

  • Set up a Performance Review System:
  • In the position description, include your expectations of the volunteer, the consequences for failing to meet those expectations and your timelines for follow-up and feedback
  • Set-up a probation period (a few weeks to a few months, depending on the volunteer’s term), conduct a consistent feedback schedule (every 6 weeks or months, for instance) and also provide ongoing feedback
  • Feedback takes many shapes:
  • Evaluation forms are often one or two paged print-outs with various quantitative data collection tools - such as scales (1 to 5), checkboxes and/or degrees – as well as qualitative feedback in the form of questions/answers and comments
  • Informal conversations can occur on a scheduled basis and allow you to have a more personal discussion with volunteers – this can help you provide genuine, face-to-face feedback and assess other areas of volunteer involvement through conversation
  • End-of-shift feedback can be a simple “thank you” or impact statement; it can also allow you to address an issue that came up during the shift and get the volunteer’s side of the story
  • Electronic follow-up utilizes web tools like SurveyMonkey or Google Forms to facilitate anonymous or otherwise feedback
  • Some key points about giving feedback:
  • When providing feedback, focus on what the volunteer can get out of it as well as the organization – remember the “give and get” of volunteering, they’re giving you their time but they’re also getting something out of it
  • Always allow for 2-way feedback, manager gives volunteer feedback, volunteer gives manager feedback
  • Make sure providing feedback is built-in and standardized, all volunteers know that it is part of their engagement (short term or long term) – this also ensures that volunteers are aware of the consequences and the serious measures associated with them
  • Reiterate the volunteer’s impact in their feedback – “because of your work, we were able to do ____” and encourage changes and improvements to increase potential impact
  • Be a coach, a guide and be there for volunteers
  • Use volunteer logs (work completed, notes, etc.) as a means to track progress and provide feedback for volunteers
  • It is not your responsibility to pass on negative feedback from someone (a community member, a staffperson or another volunteer) to the volunteer; remember that “it doesn’t matter who said it, the volunteer’s work affects everyone

Looking for more ideas on giving volunteers feedback? Stay tuned for a new Subscriber Resource Guide & Workbook on Volunteer Feedback & Evaluation in Summer 2015.

Subscriber Circles are themed discussion groups for volunteer coordinators and managers, hosted monthly by Volunteer Toronto in-house and in different parts of Toronto. Subscriber Circles are free for Full Subscribers.

Click here to see more free resources!

Featured Members
WoodGreen Community ServicesOpportunity made here.


Volunteer Toronto Office

344 Bloor Street West, Suite 404
Toronto, ON
M5S 3A7

T. 416-961-6888
F. 416.961.6859

Open To The Public



CRA# 119287092RR0001